Saturday, April 16, 2011

A-Z Action: B is for Beastmen

I'm going to talk about Tinderbox's Beastmen, the faction probably closest to what could be termed "villains" in the setting. First, though something I was reading the other day has me thinking I really should come up with some other names with them. I don't, in general, worry that my stance on anti-Common necessitates re-naming every object and race a dozen times; dudes call themselves what they call themselves, and strangers from other cultures learn to deal with it. This is not, after all, a setting where a single language rose to dominance or quasi-dominance, and the folks of one nation are named for a wholly different nation's inhabitants because one dude with three ships had trouble with maps.

The question then becomes what language to use for naming them. The circumstances that created the beastmen occurred at a time when the orcs had been brought to heel by the Tran and their human allies. The elves were also present on the surface, having been in conflict with the orcs and humans before the dwarves and their goblin army broke the surface. When the humans saw what the Tran did with the orcs, they realized that they were next; their technology was about the same level as the orc tribes, and humans of course lack any of the same physical advantages. Since Tinderbox is a godless campaign, the human tribes turned to primal spirits for aid. They received that aid, but the only spirits who answered the call were Primordial entities. I tend to treat Spirit/Primordial as more of a continuum based on the individual's view of living things in creation. Not unlike Banes versus spirits in Werewolf, only generally shying away from the more modern psychological/industrial identities found in that game.

These spirits offered power to the desperate humans, but they were only willing to empower them in exchange for a berth in the race's "souls" (which, in keeping with the non-divine nature of the setting, would really be spirits). The initial results of this were probably "liminal" monsters---thanks for teaching me yet another way to force that word into conversation, Wizards!---gnolls, minotaur-style ungulates, bearmen, etc. However, the offspring of those creatures, as well as any humans who either entered these compacts later or produced offspring alongside the original beastmen, more closely resemble shifters. When I say shifter I include longtooth, razorclaw, or anything else I decide to work up along those lines; Eberron had a great wealth of different, evocative shifter breeds which I do miss them in the current game. The variations amongst these breeds reflect environmental and cultural alterations, but all shifters are considerably weaker and less intelligent than the majority of full-fledged beastmen.

Adolescent beastmen are consecrated to the tribe's totem Primordial...which has considerable similarities to the genasi of the Silken Kingdoms. Of course, there's not been anyone with the opportunity to make this connection since the beastmen are insular and violent, and don't talk to other races. Most beastmen are going to embrace their tribe's spirit, but some will instead be traded away to a tribe their personality fits better. Beastmen who find no acceptance amongst their totems or who descend from tribes which never earned a significant totem's allegiance are the most likely to have something resembling a nonviolent relationship with other races---frankly, they don't have the power to do much else. I'm keeping the beastmen at a technological level that's far behind even the secondary races of the Tran. This means that members of the race who don't turn into awesome gnoll-dudes are in largely the same place that the original humans were, relative to the other civilizations on the continent.

But I'm attached to the rather bland "beastmen" name because it's so accurate to what, exactly, this race is. It also serves as a unifying term for both the undifferentiated (shifter) beastmen and the more uniquely identified tribes.

On the subject of tribes, later I'm going to fling up a few statblocks from the beastmen the parties in Tinderbox have faced so far. I built most of these beastmen using an online monster builder in late 2010, back when I was without Insider access. However, I ran every one of them through the official Monster Builder when I started the game back up. I'm still refining my touch when it comes to balancing monsters, as well as just building their slate of powers, so I imagine I may alter these core creatures as time goes on.

Thursday, April 14, 2011

That A-Z Action: A is for Ambition

You know what's cool? A-Z blogging is cool.

Least, it seems to be; damn near every rpg blog I read regularly or recently is on that tip. And while I've rarely met a bandwagon I liked, this one dovetails nicely with my efforts to get more regular content updates running through Ego Poisoning.

To that end, fully aware of the shameful consequences of failure (I'd be shamed, mostly), I embark on this journey as well. It won't really change most of what I'm going to write about, realistically; just drive me to write more often, and to occasionally shoehorn a post that I wanted to make, or discussion I wanted to comment on, into a particular alphabetical niche.

For A, then, I want to talk about Ambition. Now, what got me thinking about this topic was actually the nature of this blog itself; what it started out as (Me being in a strange new town for a strange new experiment known as grad school...me occasionally being drunk and watching strange YouTube videos at 3 in the morning) and what it's gradually evolved into (Dungeons and Dragons, occasionally a movie review). It's left me wondering, somewhat, why I didn't just start a DnD blog in the first place, though ultimately I don't think that would have worked given how overwhelming the first semester of grad school was. But for the immediate future I can definitely see running this as all gaming and the occasional movie review; hell, if someone gave me money and/or digital space to yammer about films elsewhere, I'd leave Ego Poisoning as sacrosanct to just gaming.

The other, and probably larger, reason I decided to kick my 26 entries off with Ambition is my recent ruminations about campaigns, including---of course---Tinderbox. I haven't been satisfied with how either of the groups I'm running through the city are progressing, and I haven't been sure how much of the blame for that I should apportion myself (but I know it's a significant share, with what the multi-month hiatus and such). However, I recognize that a major element in my dissatisfaction is the contrast between what I envisioned for this sandbox campaign, and what I'm seeing so far from the parties.

When I set out to run Tinderbox, I knew I'd be running a continuation of Lockout; in essence, the same game but a few weeks later, giving the factions a chance to solidify and carve up the city. The core conceits, even many of the core NPCs, remained the same. It was still a game about a disparate group of individuals stuck in, effectively, a very large and very dangerous box. I still find that concept extremely attractive, all the more so because I have these grand visions for plotlines and great battles and surprises and unexpected dungeons and valuable NPCs and shifting political conflicts...and yet, the simple fact is I haven't even sat down and written Slaughterhouse statblocks for ANY of my zones. Not even the one both parties are in right now. The one that, ostensibly, they're depleting opponents from.

I have a grand vision for converting treasure parcels into Progress Points, which players can then cash in for wealth and favors. The party also accrues these points, and can use them for purchasing safehouses throughout the city. I have this vision, and I have sketches of how it plays out, but I haven't sat down and written functions to determine all of this---though I have tried to pawn that task off on my cousin, because despite being a little more than half my age she manages to make me look like a simpleton.

The most recent entry in the Architect DM series ends with the exhortation "Don't Be Afraid of World Building." I'm not, as evidenced by the cultures, races, feats, class alterations, and history I've crafted for Tinderbox. I thought out, and wrote out, three entire continents' worth of empires and peoples for a game that I knew, at its outset, was going to be about a single---albeit large---dangerous box. I love worldbuilding. I have campaigns for days.

I have not, on the other hand, named the city. At all. Anywhere. Even when it was Lockout, before. I have a city, I have a general knowledge of how the zones are laid out, I have a much better knowledge of how the factions within it interact, and I have all sorts of great vignettes involving specific encounters that I want the PCs to have at various points. I have multiple out of place NPCs I plan to seed the city with, just to give the PCs unexpected challenges or opportunities largely divorced from the whole faction concept.

But I don't have a name for the city. Because the way my ambition functions, I tend to see and hunger for this vast, intricate, detailed contraption...but quickly lose interest in the sorts of critical information one would find in the owner's manual of said contraption.

So I really should name the city...maybe something that starts with A.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Dungeons and Dragons: Nonsensical Title Before Series Subtitle- Defender Marks Part 2

Next on my laundry list of series I started in 2010 and need to complete, I'm going to wrap up talking about the non-Essentials DnD defenders and their marks. I may come back and hit up Essentials defenders at a later date, though that's probably worth no more than a supplemental mini-post.* I already covered the Fighter, Swordmage, and Battlemind in my previous post, and made a case for viewing the Fighter as the core defender chassis. Even with Essentials material available, I still stand by that claim; Essentials defender auras mostly trade targeting for choice. This makes them a deviation from the core defender concept, where selecting your marked targets is a major tactical consideration.

Without further ado, let's delve into the remaining two defenders.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Language in DnD: Part 4- Revenant Converse!

And now, at last, we come to the concluding post in the Languages in DnD series. In previous posts I covered: my issues with languages in DnD, particularly common; the cultural considerations driving the Tinderbox campaign, and how these affect the available languages; and the available languages for my campaign, alongside their mechanical benefits.

Well, I covered most of the available languages. I saved one for this post (Which will also have a passing mention of telepathy, though none of the players in either party decided to roll psionic) because its implementation relies on some additional rules I added for the campaign. These rules allow characters to learn more languages as a natural consequence of leveling, albeit at varied strata of proficiency. I feel that it's a natural and necessary balance to the strict linguistic barriers I erected for the campaign.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Back Online

Well, obviously I was never offline, so much as not providing posts here. Over the next week or so, though, I'm aiming to finish out my Fighter Mark analysis and Language series, and start looking at some new subjects to tackle.

With my Tinderbox game back up, I can finally start posting statblocks for some of the monsters the party faced; many of these blocks were done in late 2010, but since the parties hadn't come up against them yet (or had, but hadn't identified them)I didn't want to put that information out there. At this point, however, Team Ashen Mask has slaughtered many Seawolves; Sullen Embers is a bit behind, mostly because we lost far more players from that group during the hiatus.

I'll also talk a little about the sandbox conventions I've been putting into play--and the challenges thereof.

Hi internet.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Dungeons and Dragons: Skills in DnD- On the Job Training

Before I dive into the supplemental rules I’m using for languages, I’ll briefly mention the original tweak that led to these rules. It’s something I refer to as On The Job Training, and it allows an extra layer of customization for characters. Somewhere between first and third (or 11th and 13th, or 21st and 23rd) level, players determine that there is a particular skill they’re using a lot, but not trained in. At 3rd/13th/23rd level, players select this skill and receive a +1 bonus to checks with it. This bonus increases by a cumulative +1 for each odd level reached in the tier; when players attain the next tier, they simply become trained in the skill.

I like this option because it addresses something I’ve experienced in most 4e games, which is that certain skills are simply missing from the party (or in the hands of folks not especially well-suited to their use) and other characters are constantly rolling those skills despite lack of training, banking on the rp bonus to pull them through. For myself, this happens a lot because very few of my characters have diplomacy or bluff relative to how many of my characters give long speeches. I like to monologue, whether to deliver horrifying threats to humbled villains before I send their souls to the Abyss or to inspire the party to do something awesome like drop a bridge on a dragon. I don’t always create my characters with the expectation that they’ll do these things (though I’m starting to bow to it), but even if I did, many characters lack the necessary skills on their skill list to make this possible. See also my comments regarding Intimidation in my last language post.

I recognize that 4e already provides a few options for players to pick up skills they’re using (or that the party needs someone to use), but I feel that this option solves things more logically and attractively. Obviously, a player could simply take a feat to gain training in a skill, but I’m not sure I’ve ever seen one do so; it’s usually much more sensical to pick up a multiclass feat so you get the skill and something else. However, that’s usually a choice made at or around character creation. I have played characters who switched up their multiclass, but this was usually prompted by the publication of new books rather than seeking a different skill.

Characters can also retrain, but as someone who puts roleplaying pretty high on my list of priorities I struggle with the idea that Thog the barbarian suddenly forgot everything that he knew about nature in order to…hell, I don’t even know what else is on their skill list. You get the point. Plus, retraining still locks you into your skill list in the first place, which isn’t helpful if Thog is a Thaneborn who suddenly finds himself thrust into a leadership role and would like to be a bit more politic than just introducing everyone to his axe. The issues I’ve outlined in this paragraph also explain why I don’t view backgrounds as much of a solution.

I want the perception that players grow as they gain experience, and giving them an incremental bonus as they increase their familiarity with a skill dos this. I suppose I could have just opened up retraining to let a player replace a skill on their list, but then they’re spending their retrain for a level, still doing that forgetting thing, and there’s the loss of a sense of learning. I don’t want Thog the Face to be a silver-tongued devil immediately, but I want players to gradually grow in confidence as his skills improve.

Now, one problem that’s already been demonstrated to me by an applicant for Tinderbox is how the on-the-job training bonus combines with Bard of All Trades; so a simple “this bonus does not stack with other feat or class bonuses” probably does the trick, since it means the character will use the higher bonus until such time as On the Job surpasses it or the skill becomes trained. I don’t tend to look at interactions like that as crises, since they usually give the player additional options and expect them to make proper choices.

This is a rule I'm using in Tinderbox, and hopefully it'll spread some of the key roles (from a skill perspective) around the party's class roles.

Language in DnD: Part 3- Headless Turtle

(My turtle is sleeping on a pair of my pajama pants right now, but with her head tucked into her shell.)

Now, the mechanical benefits section could be taken as odd or unnecessary, especially if I've already convinced you of the need for language revolution with all of my appeals to setting richness and roleplaying.

However, many of the benefits are simply psychological; someone likes to be addressed in their own language. DMs can certainly apply circumstance bonuses to reflect this, and I'd encourage it; but in the case of goblins, for instance, the effect is even more considerable. Even if I were awarding a player a +2 bonus on a Diplomacy roll for an impassioned plea for mercy from a Despot Goblin holding a spear to his throat, I'd still also give them the bonus for speaking Goblin to a goblin. The Despot is moved by the eloquence of his captive, but further moved that his captive is managing to be eloquent in Goblin. I'd apply both bonuses even if the character was also a goblin, since in that case there's the added empathy of staring into a like face.

The Draconic and Elemental Tongue bonuses (and possibly the Spirit tongue, which I'm mulling over as I type this sentence) have a bit of that extra mystical flare to them. They aren't just psychologically appealing, they're essentially appealing, in that they speak to something at the core of the audience member. The effects will presumably come into play less often in the Tinderbox campaign than the benefit of knowing Goblin. What makes them powerful, though, is their capacity for use in situations where the audience can't talk. The krask are a good borderline example, as krask are fairly unintelligent and almost never know any language other than Draconic. A player has no hope of convincing a krask to halt its charge if he calls out in Dwarven, for example; but the same command delivered in Draconic gets a boost. Players, even non-rangers, could use similar tactics when beset by guard drakes, which are a fairly common creature in the Tran Empire.